YELLOW MAGIC'S PROFILE
I am nothing special
Being Yellow Magic
An average Joe finds inspiration for an RPG Maker game in the unlikeliest of places
An average Joe finds inspiration for an RPG Maker game in the unlikeliest of places
Search
Filter
[MAFIA] RMN: When They Cry (Tea Party)
[MAFIA] RMN: When They Cry (Tea Party)
I heard you guys like LISTS, so here's a LIST of Mafia likelies:
OzzyTheOne: The roleclaim's a bit rubbish to be honest
Muffle: Seems to use a lot of the "They're being overly defensive/not posting anything substantial" argument against people despite being, honestly, the same way. I'm not sure if this is irony or being sinister
demonlord5000: This one's a bit iffy I have to admit but: The protector role doesn't seem very useful at all for Town if you need two of them to protect the same person! If we consider that the Gunmen so far (Gourd, Jeroen) are Town, what's the point of the protectors?
What I'm trying to say is I don't think being a Protector is indicative of Town in this game. Add this to the flavour text that demonlord claims to have received (hit by a vase, then ducked under a stairwell) and yes yes I know we shouldn't reason about it, but surely someone can understand why that rubs me the wrong way?
LockeZ: Process of elimination considering all the people who've role-claimed already/have decent alibis.
I also need to read Cap_H's posts again.
OzzyTheOne: The roleclaim's a bit rubbish to be honest
Muffle: Seems to use a lot of the "They're being overly defensive/not posting anything substantial" argument against people despite being, honestly, the same way. I'm not sure if this is irony or being sinister
demonlord5000: This one's a bit iffy I have to admit but: The protector role doesn't seem very useful at all for Town if you need two of them to protect the same person! If we consider that the Gunmen so far (Gourd, Jeroen) are Town, what's the point of the protectors?
What I'm trying to say is I don't think being a Protector is indicative of Town in this game. Add this to the flavour text that demonlord claims to have received (hit by a vase, then ducked under a stairwell) and yes yes I know we shouldn't reason about it, but surely someone can understand why that rubs me the wrong way?
LockeZ: Process of elimination considering all the people who've role-claimed already/have decent alibis.
I also need to read Cap_H's posts again.
[MAFIA] RMN: When They Cry (Tea Party)
[MAFIA] RMN: When They Cry (Tea Party)
As much as I enjoyed reading CAVE_DOG's zero-punctuation list, I have to admit he makes a good point regarding Ozzy. To be honest, I'm not sure why I thought Muffle's Day 2 initial post was insincere and not Big Oz's.
Hey Muffle, do you have any thoughts re: Ozzy at the moment?
Hey Muffle, do you have any thoughts re: Ozzy at the moment?
[MAFIA] RMN: When They Cry (Tea Party)
The double protector and double gunman stuff is super interesting.
I'm trying to figure out whether a double protector role would help Mafia or Town out more.
It'd be easy enough for two Mafia to protect the same person, not so much Town. What would be the odds of two Protectors, well, Protecting the same person?
I'm trying to figure out whether a double protector role would help Mafia or Town out more.
It'd be easy enough for two Mafia to protect the same person, not so much Town. What would be the odds of two Protectors, well, Protecting the same person?
[MAFIA] RMN: When They Cry (Tea Party)
[MAFIA] RMN: When They Cry (Tea Party)
author=demonlord5000
Bold letters were my indicator too, but I didn't want to delve into pm details. In my flavor they hit me over the shoulder with a vase, which is then when I dove for cover under the stairwell.
I know we're not supposed to reason about the flavour but this makes absolutely no sense. It reads like a contradiction in an Ace Attorney game.
[MAFIA] RMN: When They Cry (Tea Party)
Piano, I have a question about your hiding behind the closet. Does your flavour end there? Is there any other info about the attacker, like being a shadow or whatever?
[MAFIA] RMN: When They Cry (Tea Party)
author=pianotm
This is meta, but I've never seen anyone say that a list is scummy. In fact, most experienced players I've encountered say that a scum-list is a good thing. In fact, not posting a scum-list on day one is one of the worst things you can do. If you die night one, other players have that list to go back to.
I wouldn't know what most experienced players think, because I only ever play Mafia here. I personally don't find the scum-lists all that helpful if they're mostly regarding who they think is Town or unsure of. It also doesn't help if the list doesn't have any additional details beyond just names, e.g. Cap-H's.
Re: Ozzy's vote. He has a point: At first demonlord said he was attacked by a shadow and wasn't sure how he survived, the next he says he was hiding behind a stairwell. I could be reading into flavour a bit much, but, this DOES seem a bit off to me.














